Ask Paul: What type of pizza pans should I buy? Aluminum, steel or blue steel?

Beyond custom pans: How custom racks, stands and cabinets can increase efficiencies
February 8, 2017
What is Detroit-Style Pizza and Why is it so Popular?
February 15, 2017

Paul Tiffany, our resident food and pan expert tackles your questions about baking and pizza pans. Have a question for Paul, email us at

Hi Paul – My pizzeria chain is currently using pizza pans that are nearing the end of their life-cycle. There are quite a few options out there, including aluminum, blue steel and stainless steel. What’s the difference? What’s better? – Jeff, Rhode Island

Thanks for the question Jeff! Most metals can be used for pizza cooking, but many, like gold, are too expensive. Other metals, such as stainless steel, are poor heat conductors, and therefore not used in baking pizza crusts or baked goods.

If you’re just looking at it from a “which metal” perspective, you have two options: steel and aluminum pans. These metals dominate pizza pan production for three simple reasons:

  1. Aluminum and steel pizza pans are conductive of heat
  2. They are formable for manufacturing
  3. They are cost effective

We know why steel and aluminum are the most popular, so let’s look at performance. They are pretty equal in this area. Heavy gauge aluminum and light gauge steel have equivalent performance in baking pizza crusts and other baked goods.

However, like all bare metals, aluminum and steel pans must be seasoned to prevent dough sticking. Bare steel will also rust if not protected. This has spawned the use of tin plating or the application of an oxide coating on pans. This coating gives us blue (or black) steel pans, which have a layer of magnetite on the steel pan that protects against rust.


Metals + Coatings = Success

As you can see, we’ve moved the conversation from which type of metal should be used on pizza pans to what type of coating to use. The coating question is really more important than the metal question because the type of coating you use is going to impact the true cost of your pizza and baking pans.

Some pans may be cheaper up front, but they are going to cost more in the long-run because of constant maintenance and a short pan life-cycle. Other pans may cost more up front, but require little maintenance and have a long life-cycle.

At LloydPans, we believe the best pan and coating combination is an aluminum pan with our proprietary coating. The pan coating we use is permanent, so you’ll never have to worry about reglazing or recoating. It’s also metal utensil safe and the coating’s PTFE-free pre-seasoning means once you get your pans, you can put them to use immediately and not have to worry about additional maintenance costs.

Read more about our proprietary coating system, or, if you’re ready to buy your pans online, visit the pizza pan section of our website.